JavaScript is disabled. For a far better experience, please permit JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.

You are watching: 45 long colt vs 45-70


I"m looking come buy a new lever gun. I have actually a young name 336 in 30-30 already. I"m mostly into Target shooting and plinking. I maybe acquire into deer searching someday though. Ns don"t reload mine ammo, for this reason what cartridge would certainly be the finest money every round in manufacturing facility loadings? i think 45-70 would provide me the most selection and power. Yet I check out in manufacturing facility loadings, the 44 magnum is virtually as powerful as 45-70 and a lot cheaper. I review the 45 colt has actually a most potential, but as with 45-70 is "tuned" down for use in vintage pistol whereas 44 mag isn"t. Factory .45-70 is nice expensive, therefore I"m wondering just how much an ext range .45-70 will provide me end .44 mag in manufacturing facility loadings?Thanks
*

The 45-70 is the most powerful of these cartridges, and also as you stated it does cost the most. If you are a handloader the 45-70 is great. Otherwise, the 44 mag or 45 Colt are very close to each other, especially in a carbine.Also, feel complimentary to head over to the new members area and also introdice yourself.
NRA Life Member NAHC MemberSouthington Sportsmens association MemberCoalition the CT Sportsmen MemberCT citizens Defense organization Member
Thanks-What sort of range are you going to gain from 45-70 at factory loadings? Is the a lot more than .44 magnum? The high strength "Buffalo Bore" 45-70 ammo looks yes, really expensive. I think most advertising ammo is "loaded" under to fire in the Trapdoor Springfield. I have read that .44 magnum may also be much more powerful than the low power .45-70 manufacturing facility ammo plus the the .44 is a lighter bullet, i m sorry maybe more flatter shooting and offer more range? Is this true?
Thanks-What type of range are girlfriend going to gain from 45-70 at manufacturing facility loadings? Is that a lot more than .44 magnum? The high power "Buffalo Bore" 45-70 ammo looks yes, really expensive. I believe most advertising ammo is "loaded" under to fire in the Trapdoor Springfield. I have actually read the .44 magnum may also be an ext powerful than the low power .45-70 factory ammo plus it the .44 is a lighter bullet, i m sorry maybe an ext flatter shooting and also offer much more range? Is this true?
If you"re in search of power 보다 you do need to stay v the bigger bore calibers the you guys already discussed. The 35 Remington, 454 Casull and the 444 Marlin can likewise be considered in bar actions if strength is the sole objective, yet if you"re talking about plinking for fun without getting into rimfires, then you can want to consider the 38/357 levers. That"s about as cheap together you"re walking to obtain for centerfire, v very an excellent factory fill availabilty, and also with high finish premium 357 factory loads you have the right to still hunt some medium video game like deer and also boar in ~ close ranges. ,
I"m looking come buy a new lever gun. I have a boy name 336 in 30-30 already. I"m mostly right into Target shooting and also plinking. I maybe acquire into deer searching someday though. Ns don"t reload mine ammo, for this reason what cartridge would be the best money per round in factory loadings? i think 45-70 would offer me the most selection and power. However I review in factory loadings, the 44 magnum is almost as powerful as 45-70 and a lot of cheaper. I check out the 45 colt has a lot of potential, but as with 45-70 is "tuned" under for usage in vintage pistol whereas 44 mag isn"t. Factory .45-70 is quite expensive, for this reason I"m wondering how much much more range .45-70 will provide me end .44 mag in factory loadings?Thanks
One other thought; If you"re spring for variety and power then forget about lever actions and also get yourself a good high power bolt activity rifle chambered because that 30 cal or higher. Playing around with levers because that that function will offer you marginal outcomes at best with special really expensive high finish ammo (like lever Revolutrion), yet that"s aboout. It would certainly be choose trying to tow a 30 foot boat with a six cylinder vehicle.

See more: The Radius Of A Sphere Is 3 Inches. Which Represents The Volume Of The Sphere?


*

.45 long Colt to me is the funnest to shoot out of a lever action. Yet the .45-70 government Round is more powerful. Yet i would go with the .45 lengthy Colt. The .45-70 federal government is to big, and also its like for taking under buffalo"s. However I still love the .45-70 Government. The .44 Magnum to me is only an excellent in Revolvers.
I assumption: v i"ll save my Garand for longer selection shooting. I arrangement on gaining a 1903A3 together well. 45-70 is just method too expensive. I already have a 30-30 lever action marlin, i m sorry is decent with distance. I just didin"t know if a 45-70 would go father than a 30-30. So, maybe I have to look because that a much shorter distance lever gun through a shorter lever throw prefer in the pistol calibers or also .22 LR. Thanks-
I guess: v i"ll conserve my Garand because that longer range shooting. I setup on acquiring a 1903A3 as well. 45-70 is just means too expensive. I already have a 30-30 lever action marlin, i beg your pardon is decent with distance. I simply didin"t understand if a 45-70 would go father 보다 a 30-30. So, possibly I need to look because that a shorter distance lever gun through a much shorter lever throw prefer in the pistol calibers or also .22 LR. Thanks-
Now ns think you"re see the light as much as the distinction in big special purpose facility fire (like 45-70) and economic plinking with a lever gun. For starters shot this ballistic graph to answer several of your questions: http://www.sportsmansguide.com/Outdoors/resource/ballistics.aspx. As far as your 30 30, i think that"s fantastic chambering because that deer, boar, black bear, and other tool game. Girlfriend can also cheat up to small elk at closer ranges. It"s also one that the most available and cheapest 30 cal center fire cartridges the you"ll find on the shelves, and also you have the right to have some fun shooting that once in a while there is no breaking the bank, but your other huge bore facility fires for bar actions can get be tough to come by and also expensive because that plinking. Now for cheap shooting girlfriend can"t come close to beating the 22LR, however it"s restricted to little game favor squirrels rabbits, perhaps some foxes and also similar, and also fun shooting, however being that you currently have a center fire lever, i recommend the you obtain a lever action 22 LR. Afterwards you can consider broadening your bar collection to something else favor the 38/357 which lies what in between a bar 22 and also your bar 30.30, although categorically it"s lot closer come the 30-30. It"s just an option to have a little an ext fun and versatility for part medium game hunting and plinking in ~ a far better cost than your 30-30, however your 30-30 does currently have the medium video game hunting classification well covered. I"m simply passing this thoughts along due to the fact that it"s the most useful route if your a bar addict choose me. I in reality purchased mine levers in a tiny bit different order than what I said to you since I began off through the 22 LR, then checked out a 357 lever, and then simply recently gained my 30-30, i beg your pardon is a must have for all lever fans IMO. Good choices for 22 levers are offered by Winchester (the 9422) not currently in production, Browning has a nice tiny lever 22, not sure if it"s right now in or out of production, and Henry appears to be right now making a nice 22 lever which has actually all the external appearances of the Winchester 9422. Marlin likewise has a bar 22. I think it"s the model 39 turn off the height of my head but not certain if manufacturing is on walking or not. From what I"ve viewed on the shelves, Henry is the most typically available. Ns think Dicks Sporting Goods and also Walmart carry them for around $400.00 offer or take depending on sales and deals, however don"t ascendancy out your smaller stores for a couple of bucks. I obtained my treasured 9422 indigenous a tiny but well stocked regional gun shop (Meltzers, Garfield, NJ), and also the an individual atmosphere, assistance, and service was worth it for the few extra bucks, quite than taking care of someone form one the the common discount stores favor I pointed out above, who more than likely doesn"t offer a hoot about guns, however would rather be autumn shelves v underwear or baseballs. Just some believed for you to digest native one lever guy to another. Good luck!