Lose 1 Turn:Activate only if you control no Special Summoned monsters. Negate the effects that all distinct Summoned monsters during the turn they space Special Summoned. If an Effect Monster(s) is unique Summoned in Attack Position: adjust them to Defense Position.The question is, just how does this card work with things prefer Trishula + chained book of Eclipse, or Exciton + chained book of Moon.I"m assuming because:1) shed 1 Turn"s first effect doesn"t start a chainAnd 2) that shed 1 revolve doesn"t clues face-up monsterThat both scenarios offered would still an outcome in the monster"s result being negated? Just searching for some confirmation,Thanks
Share this postLink come postShare on various other sites
Ostaph 73
*

Ostaph 73

Tomb KeeperDuelist 73196 postsGender: Male
Posted might 12, 2015

None the the two books achieves other that transforms Trish right into a monster not thought about special summoned this turn. Thus, none of the books has relevant interaction with lose 1 Turn. Result: effect is negated.

You are watching: Lose 1 turn ruling


*
2
Share this postLink to postShare on various other sites
M.C.B. 172
*

M.C.B. 172

a machineDuelist 172816 postsGender: Male
Posted may 12, 2015

i expect judges room on this, this card begs because that missrulings


Share this postLink come postShare on various other sites
+Urthor 10297
*

Urthor 10297

You are now breathing manually+Necro Moderoid
*
1029716218 postsGender: MaleLocation: SydneyInterests: A the majority of stuff
Posted may 13, 2015

Whenever someone questions you just say "it"s choose shadow mirror other than facedown monsters space treated as special summoned"

 

Rinse and also repeat ad-nauseam 


Share this postLink come postShare on various other sites
Deladox 1
*

Deladox 1

Brave HeartDuelist 158 posts
Posted may 22, 2015
In bochum, i asked a inquiry to the head judges about reqliate and also book of eclipse, even though they are different, the head judges answer to be that face down monsters can not be negated. Don"t recognize if it simply was to explain the instance or if it uses everywhere.
Share this postLink to postShare on other sites
~ness00~ 1013
*

ness00 1013

Number VII~The Organization~ 10131348 postsGender: Male
Posted may 22, 2015

It is a usually correct statement, and it is true for Re-Qliate. I"m not certain if you are asking noþeles else.


Share this postLink to postShare on various other sites
!Shining Bind! 220

!Shining Bind! 220

Absolute DominationLoyalist 220387 posts
Posted may 25, 2015
I heard that it to be ruled that book of Moon won"t prevent the negation of lose 1 turn at YCS Columbus. Deserve to anyone that was there confirm that?
Share this postLink come postShare on various other sites
~ness00~ 1013

ness00 1013

Number VII~The Organization~ 10131348 postsGender: Male
Posted might 26, 2015

Yeah i keep acquiring it mentioned. I have the right to at least confirm the echo is real.


Share this postLink to postShare on other sites
M.C.B. 172

M.C.B. 172

a machineDuelist 172816 postsGender: Male
Posted may 26, 2015
i askedbook wont protect against the negation, monster leaving field will
Share this postLink come postShare on other sites
Jamie almost everywhere 145

Jamie all Over 145

Tomb KeeperDuelist 145235 postsGender: Male
Posted may 26, 2015

i askedbook wont protect against the negation, monster leaving ar will


 

i asked the hj ~ above friday around chaining el to construct"s effect using build for the fusion, reportedly construct would certainly "remain negated since it is quiet a distinct summoned monster as soon as the chain resolves"


Share this postLink to postShare on other sites
~ness00~ 1013

ness00 1013

Number VII~The Organization~ 10131348 postsGender: Male
Posted might 26, 2015
because that is tho a unique summoned monster when the chain resolves

 

It is, however :^)


Share this postLink to postShare on various other sites
Dirk 1957

Dirk 1957

Dirk SquadDuelist 1957866 postsGender: Not TellingLocation: Bumblefuck
Posted might 26, 2015

So can you explain how it works, im sure world are searching for a explanation rather of "ask your head judge"


Share this postLink to postShare on other sites
~ness00~ 1013

ness00 1013

Number VII~The Organization~ 10131348 postsGender: Male
Posted might 26, 2015

So have the right to you define how that works, im sure human being are trying to find a explanation instead of "ask her head judge"


 

It works similar to skill Drain, the monster demands to it is in face-up. That doesn"t negate impacts like Exiled pressure (they use an Infernoid as an example, yet it"s the very same thing), and also then we had to asking if book stops it and also they stated yes. While the may too be an intern, every other ruling stays clear of the issue and also makes it work-related like skill Drain.But due to the fact that it doesn"t speak "face-up", your judge will ascendancy it as needing to it is in face-up, for this reason yeah.


*
1
Share this postLink come postShare on other sites
»Pharaoh Atem 15834

Pharaoh Atem 15834

The ruler of Benevolence - her Translator»Retired staff 1583421985 postsGender: MaleLocation: Ohio. Huffman Prairie.Interests: Hanging out with my friends and family.
Posted might 26, 2015

So can you describe how the works, ns sure human being are in search of a explanation instead of "ask your head judge"


 

Note that no one is obligated to follow ness"s explanation for it, also if you shot bringing up the OCG info for it. "Ask her HJ" is inescapable, man. It"s unsatisfying, however rules aren"t interested in satisfaction.

 

The hard part in every this is, as much as the game itself is concerned, the truth that rulings exist solely for your event and also nothing an ext is pure - there exists no answer that you can lug to all TCG events and expect will be upheld there is no rebellion or question.When ns say "ask her HJ", i don"t say it to mock you, i say the so you don"t get your really hopes up. Get me?


Share this postLink to postShare on other sites
Dirk 1957

Dirk 1957

Dirk SquadDuelist 1957866 postsGender: Not TellingLocation: Bumblefuck
Posted might 27, 2015

You don"t have issues getting other card interactions set in stone tho, and also having explanations v them. It simply seems favor laziness come not define how the cards work, or having actually something prepared for once the card releases.

 

I guess world should just spam Julia with emails till they provide a actual answer, appears to it is in the only way to get things done


Share this postLink come postShare on other sites
»Pharaoh Atem 15834

Pharaoh Atem 15834

The ruler of Benevolence - her Translator»Retired staff 1583421985 postsGender: MaleLocation: Ohio. Huffman Prairie.Interests: Hanging out with my friends and family.
Posted may 27, 2015

You don"t have problems getting other card interactions collection in rock tho, and having explanations v them. It just seems choose laziness to not define how the cards work, or having something ready for as soon as the card releases.

 

I guess human being should just spam Julia with emails till they provide a genuine answer, seems to be the only way to obtain things done


 

Actually, these problems come up every time a card works differently than the fandom expects. You say the other cards don"t get problems, yet having founded the Org year ago, I"d humbly disagree. Granted, these worries ARE my service to know...

 

The Org"s do a point to tell civilization shit doesn"t have to work the same way globally, yet folks don"t buy in. We understand how the TCG authorities dislike folks learning OCG things, in part because players don"t listen when civilization who understand OCG things say "it"s not certified to work-related the same method for you as soon as it gets to her country." us report on exactly how it functions elsewhere, and tell people "don"t i think it to it is in identical" explicitly due to the fact that we know situations like this have the right to come up.

 

Cards are permitted to work in different way in different places, and that"s never ever going to change.

 

 

 

The cards work as written, and the world entitled to interpret their writing once you and also your girlfriend have disagreements are the judges (and R&D, once R&D speaks, but R&D doesn"t speak often). The writing is the explanation, as far as R&D is concerned, because that the gross bulk of map interactions in the game.

See more: Phlegraean Fields 80078 Pozzuoli, Metropolitan City Of Naples Italy

 

 

 

That said, Julia"s not involved in these matters either, due to the fact that her project is to control the judges and the Judge program - no to decide how cards work, or relay exactly how they work. Occasionally she relays something, but it it s okay in the means of what she needs to obtain done.