The consumer Price table of contents (CPI) and also the gross domestic product (GDP) price index and implicit price deflator are steps of inflation in the U.S. Economy. The CPI procedures price alters in goods and also services purchased the end of bag by metropolitan consumers, vice versa, the GDP price index and also implicit price deflator measure price alters in goods and also services to buy by consumers, businesses, government, and foreigners, however not importers. Thus, i beg your pardon one to usage in a provided scenario relies on one’s purpose.

You are watching: Which is the most accurate statement about the gdp deflator and the consumer price index?

Inflation can be identified as a regular increase in one economy’s “price level,” or the price component of complete expenditures top top a set of goods and also services, over a offered period. The consumer Price table of contents (CPI), a product the the bureau of job Statistics (, is maybe the most widely supplied measure the inflation in the united States. The CPI actions the average change over time in the prices paid by metropolitan consumers in the United says for a market basket that goods and also services.

The personal Consumption expenditure (PCE) price index, created by the U.S. Office of Economic evaluation (BEA), is one more measure of customer inflation and also is followed very closely by the U.S. Board of Governors of the federal Reserve device (the federal Reserve). Regardless of differences in scope, weight, and methodology, the CPI and the pce price table of contents both measure up inflation native the perspective of the consumer. However, one might be interested in an index that actions price change throughout a wider or narrower range of goods and also services—for example, an table of contents that actions price change throughout a set of goods and also services that contains not just consumer goods and also services, but also goods and services to buy by businesses, government, and other entities.

One such measure up is the price index linked with the nation’s gross residential product (GDP). Every quarter, BEA release data ~ above the level of, and change in, GDP. This data include a break down of GDP into price and also quantity indexes, and a GDP latent price deflator. The GDP price index and implicit price deflator are derived from the measure of GDP, providing rise to 3 main problems that differentiate the GDP price indexes indigenous other steps of inflation. The very first issue is the scope of goods and services because that which prices are gathered and indexes space calculated. The 2nd is the weight attached to prices for these goods and also services. The 3rd is the methodological details of price index calculation.

This post compares and contrasts BEA’s GDP price index and implicit price deflator v the CPI.1


The CPI is a measure of the average change over time in the prices paid by city consumers for a constant-quality industry basket of goods and also services—that is, a sample the goods and services that consumers purchase for day-to-day living. Produced monthly, the CPI weights the price of every item in the market basket top top the communication of the amount of spending report by a sample that families and also individuals.

The CPI has two main inputs: prices and expenditure weights. Data on prices are built up from the Commodities and also Services (C&S) Survey and also Housing Survey. The C&S survey collects price data on about 80,000 goods and services every month in approximately 23,000 retail establishments in 87 metropolitan areas around the joined States. The real estate Survey collects around 6,000 rent estimates per month in the same 87 metropolitan areas. Retail establishments for i m sorry price data are collected are selected mostly via a sampling procedure that uses data native the telephone Point-of-Purchase survey (TPOPS), administered quarterly by the U.S. Census bureau on behalf of When retail facilities are selected because that price collection, ar staff employed by visit the establishments, select a unique item for pricing, and continue to collect the price data monthly or bimonthly, unless the article is no much longer sold or a various retail facility is selected in the following TPOPS rotation. Housing units room selected by means of a various survey process, one that relies on data indigenous both the decennial census and also the U.S. Census Bureau’s American neighborhood Survey for sampling.

The second primary input into the CPI, the expenditure weights, is based on Consumer Expenditure (CE) inspection data gathered by the U.S. Census Bureau because that The CE inspection identifies the disagreement amount households spend ~ above a broad selection of goods and also services. Around 14,000 1-week diaries and also 28,000 quarterly interviews are built up from the existing CE inspection sample each year.

Once price and also expenditure data room collected, price indexes have the right to be calculated v the use of price index formulas. The CPI offers a hybrid that geometric and arithmetic median calculation, relying on whether “lower level” or “upper level” indexes are being constructed. Currently, the CPI procedures price readjust for 211 item category (e.g., breakfast cereal) in 38 geographic locations (e.g., Boston–Brockton–Nashua), developing 8,018 basic item–area index cells (211 × 38) that offer as the building blocks indigenous which aggregate indexes room constructed. These structure blocks are the so-called lower level indexes. Accumulation indexes built from them space the so-called top level indexes. For example, the intermediate upper level index because that cereals and cereal commodities is built from 3 item categories: (1) flour and prepared flour mixes; (2) breakfast cereal; and (3) rice, pasta, and also cornmeal. The index because that cereals and cereal assets can be computed because that the Boston–Brockton–Nashua urban area, for a collection of urban that consist of the Northeast urban geographic area, or because that all urban in i m sorry prices room collected. The last creates an index at the level the the U.S. City average. In total, the CPI is composed of thousands of indexes that measure price adjust for small and wide categories the goods and services across multiple geographical areas. The an outcome is a set of CPI indexes that measure the average change over time in the price paid specifically by metropolitan consumers for a constant-quality industry basket that goods and also services.

The CPI provides an arithmetic mean (or Laspeyres) formula for all upper level table of contents calculation, yet employs a geometric typical for about 60 percent that all reduced level indexes in terms of weight (a Laspeyres formula is supplied for the continuing to be 40 percent). The geometric average formula allows the CPI come reflect changes in customer spending patterns amongst goods and services within item–area combinations—changes that happen in solution to transforms in relative price. The formula assumes that the adjust in amount is same (in portion terms), and inversely related, come the readjust in price. Thus, if the family member price the one brand that bananas in the Boston–Brockton–Nashua metropolitan area increases, then the quantity purchased of that brand is assumed to decrease percentagewise by the exact same amount. Similarly, if a pint of ice cream boosts in (per-unit) price loved one to a quart of ice cream cream, climate the amount purchased the a pint is assumed to decrease through a portion reflective the the readjust in relative price.2

Unlike the geometric mean formula, the Laspeyres formula applied in the CPI is one arithmetic median of price relatives weighted by expenditures that implicitly contain info on quantity. Because expenditure data are updated every 2 years, the month-to-month changes in upper level CPI indexes reflect price adjust under the presumption that quantity remains fixed. This assumption means that the CPI does not account because that real-time changes that may happen in expenditure shares throughout aggregate categories of goods and also services, probably in an answer to transforms in family member price across the same aggregate categories. In short, the Laspeyres formula introduce “consumer substitution bias” right into the CPI; that is, it does not account for the possibility that consumers will switch to different commodities or shop in various outlets in response to increases in the price of nearby substitutes.

In sum, the CPI is a measure of price change across a set of goods and also services purchased by metropolitan consumers and also is calculated with the use of a mix of geometric and arithmetic means that can catch some level of customer substitution restricted to goods and services in ~ item groups.

GDP price indexes

BEA is responsible for producing the national Income and Product accounts (NIPAs). According to BEA, “The NIPAs room a collection of financial accounts that administer information on the value and composition of output developed in the united States throughout a given period and top top the species and supplies of the income generated by the production.”3 The NIPAs are among the three significant components that the U.S. National financial accounts. The others room the industry (input–output) accounts ready by BEA and also the jae won (flow-of-funds) accounts all set by the commonwealth Reserve.4 Together, the national economic accounts present a macrolevel diagnosis that the health and wellness of the U.S. Economy and also encompass the complete scope that economic task in the nation.

The NIPAs measure, in particular, (1) domestic income and product (i.e., output), (2) private enterprise income, (3) personal income and outlays, (4) federal government receipts and expenditures, (5) foreign transactions, (6) the domestic capital account, and also (7) the foreign transactions capital account. The NIPA domestic income and product account gives expenditure and income recaps of GDP. GDP is one of the most important and closely adhered to NIPA accounts and measures the industry value of final goods and also services developed by the U.S. Economy over a provided period.5 The expenditure and income ideologies reflect two of the three ways to calculation GDP: (1) as the amount of goods and also services sold to last users (expenditures approach); and (2) as the sum of income payments and other costs incurred in the production of goods and also services (income approach). The 3rd approach calculates GDP as the sum of “value added” by all sectors in the economic situation (the manufacturing approach).6

The expenditures technique “is supplied to determine the last goods and also services to buy by persons, businesses, governments, and also foreigners” and reflects a summation of personal consumption expenditures, gross private fixed investment, change in private inventories, network exports that goods and services, and also government intake expenditures and also gross investment.7 The expenditures strategy is possibly the most intuitive for portraying the differences in scope in between the CPI and the GDP price index. In this approach, the four straightforward categories of expenditures that contribute to GDP are expenditures make by consumers, businesses, government, and foreigners. BEA constructs a price index because that each of these categories, and also the assorted price indexes room aggregated into the all at once GDP price index because that the unified States.

See more: Gilbert A British Tar Lyrics "A British Tar", A British Tar

The GDP price index, like the CPI, actions price adjust for consumer goods and also services, but additionally measures price change for goods and also services purchased by businesses, governments, and also foreigners. However, unlike the CPI, the GDP price table of contents does not measure price readjust for imports.

Although the GDP price index and the CPI both measure alters in the price of goods and services purchase by consumers, the GDP depends on the pce price index as its measure of change in consumer prices. Also, vice versa, the CPI provides a Laspeyres formula, the pce price index counts on a Fisher ideal price index calculation.8 In addition, the CPI weights are obtained from out-of-pocket expenditure by consumers, if the sprayed weights are derived from out-of-pocket expenditures by consumers and also third-party expenditures on behalf of consumers.9 Finally, the yes, really goods and also services for which prices are gathered vary. (For example, the CPI because that financial services includes only check accounts and other financial institution services, and also tax return preparation and other bookkeeping fees, and also has much less than a 0.5-percent re-publishing in the CPI, conversely, the sprayed is an ext expansive and includes pension funds, regulated investment service providers such as common funds, and also securities commissions).10

The GDP price table of contents is calculated with a Fisher best index formula, i m sorry is may be to pick up changes in the allocation of expenditure by consumers across the wide categories of customer goods and also services extended by GDP. The GDP price table of contents is similar in concept to the chained CPI-U, or CPI for All metropolitan Consumers.11